If a car accident in Manchester, New Hampshire, worsens an injury or medical condition you already had, you may seek compensation for the additional harm caused by another person’s negligence. A previous diagnosis does not automatically disqualify your claim. The main issue is what changed because of the collision, including your symptoms, ability to work, treatment needs, and daily activities. Medical records from before and after the accident can help establish that difference.
New Hampshire law recognizes claims involving aggravated pre-existing conditions. The amount you may recover depends on evidence of negligence, medical causation, and the harm attributable to the crash.
Can You File a Car Accident Claim If You Already Had an Injury?
Yes. You may bring a car accident claim even if you previously had back pain, arthritis, a neck injury, a spinal condition, or another diagnosed medical problem. The law does not require you to have been in perfect health before the accident.
Your claim focuses on whether the collision caused a new injury, made an existing condition worse, or caused symptoms and limitations that you otherwise would not have experienced at that time. An insurer may compare your earlier medical history with your condition following the crash.
What Counts as Aggravation of a Pre-Existing Injury?

An aggravated pre-existing injury is a previously existing condition that becomes worse because of an accident. The change may involve increased pain, new symptoms, reduced mobility, additional medical treatment, or a lasting loss of function.
Examples may include:
- An existing herniated disc that produces more severe pain or new radiating symptoms after a rear-end collision.
- Arthritis that becomes more painful and limits movement following a crash.
- A previous neck injury that requires renewed treatment because symptoms increase after the accident.
- A formerly healed fracture or previously injured area that develops new accident-related problems.
- Chronic back pain that becomes more disabling and interferes with regular work duties.
An aggravation does not always require a new finding on an imaging study. A medical professional may evaluate changes in symptoms, examination findings, physical function, and treatment requirements. The evidence must still connect the worsening to the accident.

James J. Tenn, Jr.
Attorney

Mary Elizabeth Tenn
Attorney

John J. Tenn
Attorney
How Does New Hampshire Law Address Pre-Existing Conditions?
New Hampshire recognizes that negligent conduct may aggravate a condition that existed before an injury event. Under the legal principle sometimes called the eggshell plaintiff rule, a responsible party generally takes the injured person as that person was found. A person with greater physical susceptibility does not lose protection merely because the same collision might have caused less harm to someone else.
In Peterson v. Gray, 137 N.H. 374 (1993), the New Hampshire Supreme Court explained that a defendant’s conduct need not be the sole cause of an injury and addressed the need to properly instruct a jury on aggravation of a pre-existing condition. The decision arose from a medical negligence case, but its discussion of causation and aggravation is relevant to negligence claims more broadly.
Legal decision: https://law.justia.com/cases/new-hampshire/supreme-court/1993/137-nh-374.html
The distinction is essential: an at-fault driver may be responsible for accident-related worsening, but not for the ordinary progression of a condition that would have occurred regardless of the collision. A medical opinion may help distinguish those possibilities.
Why Do Insurance Companies Review Earlier Medical Problems?
Insurance adjusters often review a claimant’s medical history to determine whether the same body part was symptomatic before the accident. They may consider previous diagnoses, prescription records, treatment gaps, prior collisions, and symptoms reported to doctors.
Earlier medical records can also support your claim. For example, a history showing that you returned to work, completed therapy, or managed a condition without major restrictions can help document a change after the crash. Provide accurate information about both periods. Concealing prior treatment can undermine credibility.
How Can You Prove That the Crash Made an Existing Injury Worse?
The strongest evidence often compares your condition before the car accident with your condition afterward. The following categories can help establish the timing, nature, and consequences of the aggravation.
Medical Records From Before the Collision
- Earlier diagnoses, imaging results, and treatment plans.
- Records describing previous pain levels, symptom frequency, and functional limitations.
- Documentation that treatment had ended or the condition was stable.
- Work records or medical notes showing activities you could perform before the crash.
Medical Records After the Collision
- Emergency evaluations, follow-up visits, and specialist assessments.
- New examination findings, diagnostic testing, or recommended procedures.
- Physical therapy records documenting changes in strength, mobility, or pain.
- Notes describing how symptoms affect sleep, driving, lifting, and work.
Medical Opinions and Other Supporting Evidence
Your treating clinician may be able to explain whether the collision caused or materially contributed to the worsening, based on your medical history, examination, test results, and symptom progression. Employment records, witness observations, and a dated journal of daily limitations may provide additional context.
**Key point:** The question is not simply whether you had an earlier injury. It is whether reliable evidence shows additional harm caused by this accident.
See What Our Clients Are Saying About Us

Attorney John Tenn and his entire team are amazing people! If you need a lawyer, he is the man to call! He handled my case in a professional matter and took the stress out of it all.
Mallory C.
![]()

The whole team were very professional and responsive. My case was effectively handled with good communication during the process. Very satisfied with the outcome. Highly recommend!
A. McMillan
![]()
What Compensation May Be Available for an Aggravated Injury?
If you can establish that another person’s negligence caused the collision and aggravated your condition, you may be eligible for damages tied to that additional injury. Depending on the facts, damages may include:
- Medical expenses for reasonable accident-related assessment and treatment.
- Future care costs supported by medical evidence.
- Lost wages resulting from accident-related restrictions or time away from work.
- Reduced earning capacity when lasting limitations affect future employment.
- Pain, suffering, and emotional effects associated with the worsening condition.
- Loss of enjoyment of activities you previously could perform.
The amount recoverable depends on the evidence, the extent of accident-related harm, liability, and any applicable legal limitations. A claim generally does not include losses unrelated to the crash.
Example of a Previous Back Injury Made Worse by a Car Crash
Consider a hypothetical Manchester resident with a previously treated lumbar disc injury. Before the crash, the person works full time and occasionally experiences manageable discomfort. After another driver causes a rear-end collision, the resident develops persistent lower back pain, leg numbness, and difficulty standing for long periods.
The insurer argues that the old disc problem explains the symptoms. Earlier records showing stable function, new treatment records, and a clinician’s opinion could help determine whether the crash caused additional harm. Compensation would focus on that supported increase in injury, rather than every medical issue involving the person’s back.
What Should You Do If a Crash Worsens an Old Injury?
- Seek medical attention promptly when you notice new or worsening symptoms. Call emergency services for urgent symptoms.
- Tell medical providers about your previous condition and describe exactly how your symptoms have changed.
- Keep accident photographs, police or crash information, correspondence, medical bills, and treatment records.
- Follow the medical guidance you receive and report changes in your condition accurately.
- Document changes to your work, household responsibilities, sleep, and normal activities.
- Consider legal advice before signing a settlement release or giving a detailed recorded statement.
For additional steps following a collision, read: https://www.tennandtenn.com/what-to-do-if-youre-in-a-new-hampshire-auto-accident/
Does a Pre-Existing Injury Affect Who Is at Fault?
Having an earlier injury does not, by itself, mean you were responsible for the collision. Fault for the crash and medical causation are different issues. New Hampshire RSA 507:7-d uses modified comparative fault. A person may recover when that person’s fault is not greater than the fault of the defendant, or the combined fault of the defendants where the statute permits recovery. Any damages are reduced by the percentage of fault attributed to the claimant.
Read the statute: https://gc.nh.gov/rsa/html/LII/507/507-7-d.htm
The comparative fault rule is not an automatic reduction based on medical history. A separate question is what portion of the claimed injury the collision caused.
How Long Do You Have to File a New Hampshire Claim?
Under RSA 508:4, I, most New Hampshire personal injury lawsuits must be commenced within three years of the act or omission at issue. The statute contains a discovery provision for qualifying circumstances in which the injury and its causal relationship could not reasonably have been discovered earlier. Different rules and deadlines may apply in particular cases.
Read the statute: https://gc.nh.gov/rsa/html/LII/508/508-4.htm
You should not assume that the discovery provision extends the deadline in your situation. Early legal advice can help identify the applicable date and preserve medical and accident evidence.
Millions in Verdicts & Settlements
The attorneys at Tenn And Tenn are ready to help you solve your legal problems and obtain results.
$9,000,000
Pedestrian Accident
$2,225,000
Motorcycle Collision
$2,224,000
CarAccident
Frequently Asked Questions About Pre-Existing Injuries and Car Accidents
Can I recover compensation if I had chronic pain before the crash?
Potentially. If the collision made the chronic pain worse or caused additional limitations, you may seek damages for that supported increase in harm.
What if my earlier condition caused no symptoms before the accident?
An accident may cause a previously asymptomatic condition to become symptomatic. Medical evidence and the sequence of events can help establish whether the crash caused the change.
Should I tell the insurer about an earlier injury?
Be truthful when asked about relevant medical history. An attorney can help evaluate the scope of medical records and requests for information.
Can I recover damages if the aggravated injury is permanent?
Potentially. When supported by medical and other evidence, a lasting accident-related aggravation may support claims involving future treatment, reduced earning capacity, and other damages.
Do I need new imaging to show aggravation?
Not always. Imaging may be useful, but clinical findings, treatment history, symptom changes, and medical opinions can also be relevant. The required proof depends on the case.
Speak With a Manchester Car Accident Attorney About an Aggravated Injury
If a car accident made an existing medical condition worse, Tenn And Tenn, PA can review the circumstances of the crash, your medical history, and insurance concerns. The firm represents injured people in Manchester, New Hampshire, and nearby communities throughout the state, using a personalized, client-centered approach.
Contact Tenn And Tenn, PA to request a consultation and discuss your legal options.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its specific facts, medical evidence, and applicable law.














